The following entry presents an overview of Said's career through Palestinian-born American critic and essayist. A Palestinian refugee in his youth and a respected though controversial professor of English and comparative literature at Columbia University, Said pronounced sah-EED is an influential and often polemical cultural critic. Said is a public intellectual who frequently writes about the Arab-Israeli conflict in the Middle East and actively supports the cause for Palestinian national rights.
During the ten years that have passed since his death there have been no signs that his extraordinary influence is diminishing. More than forty books have been published about him, including even a few critical ones, but mostly adulatory, such as The Cambridge Introduction to Edward Said, published seven years after his death of leukemia in Related Essay Joshua Muravchik essay Joshua Muravchik reviews the history and flaws of the latest school of American interventionism.
Rather than shout this accusation from a soapbox, as others had done, Said delivered it in tones that awed readers with erudition. The names of abstruse contemporary theoreticians and obscure bygone academicians rolled off pages strewn with words that sent readers scurrying to their dictionaries.
In truth, Said was an unlikely symbol of the wretched of the earth. His father, who called himself William, had emigrated from Jerusalem a place he hated, according to Edward to America inserved in World War I, and become a US citizen. Reluctantly yielding to family pressures, he returned to the Middle East in the s and settled in Cairo, where he made his fortune in business and married an Egyptian woman.
Edward, their eldest after a first-born had perished in infancy, was told he was named after the Prince of Wales. He and his four sisters were reared in the Protestant church and in relative opulence, with a box at the opera, membership in country clubs, and piano lessons.
They were edward said essays for scholarships at British and American primary and secondary schools in Cairo until Edward was sent to an elite New England prep school at fifteen, then to Princeton.
Fifteen years earlier, the Palestine Liberation Organization had been founded in the effort to consecrate a distinctive Palestinian identity, and the announcement of that identity to the world had mostly taken the form of spectacular acts of terror whose purpose was in large measure to draw attention to Palestinian grievances.
He brought authenticity to this task because of his origins and authority because of his membership in the Palestinian National Council, the nominal governing body of the PLO. Abracadabra—Israel was transformed from a redemptive refuge from two thousand years of persecution to the very embodiment of white supremacy.
There was one final step in this progression: Edward Said as the emblematic Palestinian.
A sympathetic writer in the Guardian put it: But in SeptemberCommentary published an investigative article by Justus Reid Weiner presenting evidence that Said had largely falsified his background. A trove of documents showed that until he moved to the United States to attend prep school inSaid had resided his entire life in Cairo, not Palestine.
A few months later, Said published his autobiography, which confirmed this charge without acknowledging or making any attempt to explain the earlier contrary claims that he had made in discussing his background.
In his rebuttal, Said had written somewhat implausibly: Even so, he did not always avoid crossing the line or dancing so close to it that whether his words should be labeled a lie or merely a deception amounted to a difference without a distinction.
But, as his critics continued to ask, does finally telling his story truthfully wipe away twenty years of lying about it? In the end, Said downplayed the matter. In a late interview with the New York Times he said: I never have represented my case as the issue to be treated.
The intellectual deceit was especially obvious in his most important book, Orientalism. Its central idea is that Western imperial conquest of Asia and North Africa was entwined with the study and depiction of the native societies, which inevitably entailed misrepresenting and denigrating them.
Another dogma is that abstractions about the Orient. A third dogma is that the Orient is eternal, uniform, and incapable of defining itself. A fourth dogma is that the Orient is at bottom something either to be feared. He had written that the Muslim conquest of Turkey preceded that of North Africa, but in reality it followed by about four hundred years.
More serious still was his lack of scruple in the use of sources. On a broad view, Said fundamentally misrepresented his subject. Because he knew that if he had asserted merely that some Westerners wrote pejoratively or condescendingly or misleadingly about the East while others did not, his argument would have lost much of its provocation.
It would have demanded clarification about the relative numbers or influence of the two groups, about variations within the groups, about reciprocal attitudes among Easterners toward the West. Above all, it would have drawn the inevitable retort:May 05, · Leone was among the 20 seniors in Mahoning, Trumbull and Columbiana counties awarded scholarships of $7, each during the Edward J.
DeBartolo Memorial Scholarship Foundation luncheon Friday at. Edward Said Essay Words | 3 Pages. In "States" the author, Edward Said, discloses the story of his people, the Palestinians, in an epic to express to the world the disconcerting challenges endured by the struggling Palestinian culture.
Enough Said: The False Scholarship of Edward Said Joshua Muravchik C olumbia University’s English Department may seem a surprising place from which to move the world, but this is what Professor Edward Said accomplished.
Edward W. Said – The following entry presents an overview of Said's career through Palestinian-born American critic and essayist.
Scholarships Learn More > Are you an educator? Essays on Cross-Cultural Encounter. Albany: State University of New York Press, William D. Edward Said and the Religious Effects of Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, Senior Vice President and Provost Jonathan Wickert said when he was a student, than to hurry through 50 essays for scholarships for which you may not be qualified.
Edward Russell Jun